James Leroy Wilson's one-man magazine.

Tuesday, March 18, 2025

Ranking the NCAA Men's Tournament Teams

 

Photo: Public Domain


I'm testing a new way to predict the outcome of the NCAA Tournament. 


First, I ranked all 68 teams based on their RPI (Rating Percentage Index) with a significant adjustment. I took each team's RPI and then subtracted the percentage of games in which the team lost by seven points or more. 


I reason that in most years, every team loses multiple games. Seven-point losses, while they may have been competitive games for the most part, weren't close games. The better teams keep it close to the very end, and I'm using that as a guide to predict how teams will fare in the Tournament.


I then used my ranking to fill out my bracket. I began with the #1 team and filled in all the spots to Champion. Then, I took the next team down and filled all the spots until it ran into an already filled spot. I did this until the bracket was complete, except for one spot.


The one open spot is Illinois (56th) vs. the winner of Xavier (37th) vs Texas (64th) in a play-in game. If Xavier beats Texas, I'll have them beating Illinois as well; if Texas beats Xavier, I'll have Illinois beating Texas. I'll fill that in after Xavier-Texas is decided.


The ranking below shows each team's seeding and abbreviated region name, followed by their adjusted RPI. Sweet Sixteen teams are in bold, and the Final Four teams are in bold and italics. After the top five spots, several teams are seeded much lower than where my ranking has them. They're much better than the Selection Committee thinks. 


Overall, however, the bracket is pretty generic:


  • Only eight (or nine, depending on Xavier-Texas) lower seeds will win in the 32 "Round of 64" games.

  • Six teams seeded fifth or lower will make the Sweet Sixteen

  • One team seeded lower than third will make the Elite Eight

  • One team seeded lower than first will make the Final Four and Championship game.


We know that upsets will happen, but how can we predict them? I'm hypothesizing that a team's performance in losses might be a predictor of Tournament success. This hypothesis is about to be tested.


Please let me know in the comments if you will use this ranking as a guide to filling out (one of) your bracket(s). I'm curious how it would fare in various-sized pools and would like to hear from you if you borrow this:


  1. Duke 1-E .657

  2. Houston 1-MW .652

  3. St. John's 2-W .639

  4. Florida 1-W. .633

  5. Auburn 1-S .629

  6. Maryland 4-W .601

  7. Drake 11-W .572

  8. Saint Mary's 7-E .567

  9. Tennessee 2-MW .567

  10. Michigan St 2-S .559

  11. Clemson 5-MW .558

  12. Liberty 12-E .549

  13. High Point 13-MW .547

  14. VCU 11-E .540

  15. Texas Tech 3-W .533

  16. Memphis 5-W .522

  17. Alabama 2-E .520

  18. Yale 13-S .520

  19. Gonzaga 8-MW .513

  20. New Mexico 10-S .509

  21. Michigan 5-S .507

  22. Wisconsin 3-E .493

  23. UConn 8-W .482

  24. Utah St 10-MW .477

  25. Kentucky 3-MW .476

  26. Akron 13-E .592 .474

  27. McNeese 12-MW .457

  28. Texas A&M 4-S .456

  29. UNC Wilmington 14-W .450

  30. Iowa St 3-S .447

  31. Louisville 8-S .442

  32. Oregon 5-E .437

  33. UCSD 12-S .436

  34. Ole Miss 6-S. .435

  35. Troy 14-MW .422

  36. Marquette 7-S .417

  37. Xavier* 11-MW .412

  38. Bryant 15-S .412

  39. Robert Morris 15-E .404

  40. BYU 6-E .401

  41. Grand Canyon 13-W .396

  42. North Carolina*11-S .394

  43. Lipscomb 14-S .389

  44. Miss St 8-E .388

  45. Colorado St  12-W .381

  46. Purdue 4-MW .377

  47. Missouri 6-W .375

  48. Arizona 4-E. .372

  49. Creighton 9-S .370

  50. UCLA 7-MW .366

  51. Kansas 7-W .361

  52. Baylor 9-E .361

  53. Oklahoma 9-W .353

  54. Montana 14-E .353

  55. San Diego State*11-S .352

  56. Illinois 6-MW. .347

  57. Arkansas 10-W .320

  58. Norfolk St 16-W .316

  59. Georgia 9-MW .315

  60. SIU-Edwardsville 16-MW . .313

  61. Wofford 15-MW .289

  62. Mt St Mary's* 16-E .262

  63. Omaha 15-W. .259

  64. Texas* 11-MW .251

  65. American 16-E*. .246

  66. Vanderbilt 10-E .224

  67. Alabama St* 16-S .143

  68. Saint Francis* 16-S .138


*Teams with an asterisk have a play-in game; aside from Xavier-Texas, the bracket isn't impacted by the play-ins.



James Leroy Wilson writes The MVP Chase (subscribe). Thank you for your subscription and support! James is available for writing, editing, research, and other work: jamesleroywilson-at-gmail.com.

No comments:

Post a Comment